It was clear from the results and the poor turn-out that although the public were clearly very very annoyed at the Tories and their lack of delivery, they were not particularly keen on Labour either. In England & Wales especially, the presence of the 'wild card' of Reform UK heavily influenced the results, costing the Tories over 100 seats that switched from Tory to Labour, in which a Reform UK candidate also stood. In Scotland the on-going damage done to the SNP by the Sturgeon scandal was all too clear.
What is strikingly clear from the data is that there is no great appetite for Labour or for Starmer. He is the most unpopular Prime Minister to win a General Election and enter No 10 on record with a -21 rating. He has taken fewer votes than his predecessor (Corbyn) lost with in 2019 & 2017, and really owes his victory to three things - Nigel Farage of Reform UK who has gutted the Tory vote, a sharp fall in turn-out (down 7% on 2019) and the vagueries of the UK's 'First-Past-The-Post' constituency voting system which produces strong governments at the expense of representation. Even Starmer's vote in his own seat was 17% down on 2019.
What is clear is the Brexit vote combined with the impact of Covid and the inflationary effects of the early part of the Ukraine war are still rippling through the electorate. The voters are no longer prepared to give politicians a chance - or indeed even give them a break. They are not interested anymore in what politicians try to do - regarding trying and failing as just failure and they now demand and expect 'delivery'. If you say you will do it, you either do exactly that no matter what happens along the way (wars, Courts, Covid etc) or they will turn on you with a vengeance. This may well be the reason Starmer has been very very careful to promise or offer very little in his election campaign and what he has promised has been deliberately vague and light on detail.
Starmer probably now plans to delay the summer recess by at least a month in order to punch through several Acts straight away (it is customary for new governments to hit the ground running. It gets progressively harder to do things the longer you are in Office). His big problem is his promises (few that there are). The money simply is not there. And he is very quickly either going to have to raise secondary taxes considerably (car tax, fuel duty, alcohol duty, IHT, CGT, TV licence etc etc) - and very very quickly, possibly introduce a new 'super level' of VAT on luxury items such as new cars, possibly even tinker with VAT thresholds on small businesses a slightly and lower them, or massively scale-back on what little he has promised. To meet his first year's promises he needs to increase the total tax take by tens of billions or increase GDP by 4% during the next 6 months - which is nigh on impossible - and although we are the fastest growing major western economy it is very fragile and squeezing extra tax could kill that recovery and spark a recession.
The new Labour government will now enter a period known as a 'loveless honeymoon' - they aren't there because the voters wanted them, they are there because the voters looked the other way or looked elsewhere (Reform UK Green etc) and they sneaked in on the rails. It will be an 'adrenaline-free' first few years and a case of 'meet the new boss, same as the old boss'.
Labour's big difficulty is going to be the same as the Tories was - immigration. Labour don't seem to grasp that the majority of the electorate do not want the boat people processing faster (ie granting right to remain) - they want them throwing out and bollocks to what the ECHR says or what state their original countries are in.
And finally, Labour have won with 33% of a 60% turn-out. That means 80% of the registered electorate either did not vote for them, or did not vote at all. In fact more registered voters did not vote than voted for them. And that is something he is going to be very very aware of every day of his tenure. It was best described in the media as a 'miles wide majority, that is only inches deep'. And as Boris Johnson can attest, when you have a large majority, you face continued back-bench rebellions.
(this is the 'Top Table)
Rt Hon sir Keir Starmer KC KCB MP
Prime Minister Of The United Kingdom
First Lord Of The Treasury
Minister For The Civil Service
Minister For The Union
Rt Hon Angela Rayner MP
Deputy Prime Minister
Secretary of State For Housing, Communities & Local Government
Rt Hon Rachel Reeves MP
Chancellor Of The Exchequer
Hon Wes Streeting MP
Secretary Of State For Health & Social Care
Hon Liz Kendall MP
Secretary Of State For Work & Pensions
Rt Hon John Healey MP
Secretary Of State For Defence
Hon Peter Kyle MP
Secretary Of State For Science, Innovation & Technology
Hon Shabana Mahmood MP
Secretary Of State For Justice
Lord Chancellor
Hon Jonathan Reynolds MP
Secretary Of State For Business & Trade
President Of The Board Of Trade
Hon Louise Haigh MP
Secretary Of State For Transport
Secretary Of State For Culture, Media & Sport
Hon Ian Murray MP
Secretary Of State For Scotland
Hon Jo Stevens MP
Secretary Of State For Wales
Rt Hon Hilary Benn MP
Secretary Of State For Northern Ireland
Hon Anneliese Dodds MP
MInister Of State For Development
Rt Hon Pat McFadden MP
Chancellor Of The Duchy Of Lancaster
Hon Darren Jones MP
Chief Secretary To The Treasury
Hon Lucy Powell MP
Leader Of The House Of Commons
Lord President Of The Council
Rt Hon The Baroness Angela Smith PC
Leader Of The House of Lords
Lord Keeper Of The Privy Seal
Rt Hon sir Alan Campbell MP
Chief Whip Of The House Of Commons
Parliamentary Secretary To The Treasury
Mr Richard Hermer KC
Attorney General For England & Wales
Advocate General For Northern Ireland
Rt Hon Mr Simon Case CVO
Cabinet Secretary
Head Of The Home Civil Service
(This is THE main man. Not the politicians.)
(This is the real 'sir Humphrey')
No comments:
Post a Comment